Skip to main content

Review: Not Precisely Mr. Knightley - The Silver Teapot #2

Not Precisely Mr. Knightley book cover on blue background

I love that I've been able to read about Dream Match, a dating app, in some of Carolyn Miller's other books and that I get to find out more about the origin story in this book.

Not Precisely Mr. Knightley is the second book in The Silver Teapot series, and it's exactly the type of modern world I can see Emma thriving in, complete with the opportunity to matchmake virtual strangers on a scaled up basis. Offering both potential and pitfalls, it's only a matter of time before we see Emma discover what true matchmaking is all about.

Many thanks to Barbour Books and NetGalley for providing a complimentary copy of this book for review consideration. All opinions are my own.

Book Synopsis

Can the Matchmaker Find True Love?

Emma-Jane (EJ) Bennett and Jordan Knight are longtime best friends who codesigned the immensely successful dating app, Dream Match. Success starts to go to EJ’s head when she gets caught up in the famous and money-hungry social circles and starts dating the son of a TV mogul. But Jordan’s feelings have grown from friendship to more. He determines to protect her by exposing Eric Churchill for the two-timer he is, finally agreeing to attend a function with her at the Sydney Opera House. But his best intentions go awry when EJ is embarrassed and runs for the security of home, small-town roots, and The Silver Teapot Café, feeling like Jane Austen’s chastised Emma―only without her Mr. Knightley.

Source: Amazon

Book Thoughts

Oh, this book had me feeling all the emotions, including irritation, frustration, contrition, and joy. In other words, all the things that make us human. It's no secret that the author is able to evoke such responses based on how real she gets in her stories. Characters are three-dimensional and they become people whom you want to hug and sometimes offer a hard truth to at the same time (in love, of course). Emma-Jane, or EJ as she prefers to be called, is no exception. Seeing her gradual descent into hurtful thinking and behaviours, I couldn't help but want her to see just what she was doing to herself in her pursuit of the good life. That's the same attitude that Jordan, her best friend, has adopted, which allowed me to step into his shoes while witnessing EJ in her actions. Yet, it wouldn't be a Carolyn Miller book without that mirror being turned around on us as readers where we can witness the very same things happening in our lives that we need deliverance from.

I love that this isn't an easy story to read because it shows how quickly things can escalate when we operate in our own strength instead of the Lord's. With many nods to Jane Austen, including a touch of the Crawford siblings in the form of new advisers and potential investors, there are an incredible amount of Easter eggs to unearth in this modern rendition of Emma. Even when we are at our most unlikeable and stubborn, God still pursues and redeems us when we call out to Him. Readers looking for books that don't gloss over seemingly innocuous sins will appreciate the end result of God refining us through the help of His people, especially when they become the Mr. Knightleys who care enough to say something and to lovingly offer correction. Those scenes alone in this book will strike your heart while expounding biblical truths about who we really we and who we belong to.

Book Summary

  • Format of book: 📱
  • Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
  • Recommendation: 👍

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Christian Book Review Programs

Over time, I've been on the hunt for Christian book review programs that readers can join. As a result, I've been able to compile the following list which may be of interest if you are seeking review copies of Christian books. This list mostly applies to print and ebooks, although some publishers offer audiobooks as well. If further information is available for any of the publishers below (or any missing publishers), please let me know as I am happy to update this list—thank you! Please note that you can also search for these publishers on NetGalley and other review sites in case there are no review programs available or you don't qualify for one 😊 List last updated: June 4, 2026 Christian Publishers 10ofThose Availability: US, Canada, and UK residents Format: Only books published by 10ofThose qualify for review requests so as to avoid impeding with other Christian book review programs Genre: Christian non-fiction, children's books Email for availability and eligibilit...

All the Cheese

I've been coming across content within the past several weeks that has stereotyped Christian books (and other mediums) as being cheesy on Christian accounts. While this isn't a new label or even a new topic, what has surprised me somewhat has been seeing more Christian authors jump into this conversation who wholeheartedly agree with this sentiment. Although some authors will name others whom they believe are writing non-cheesy fiction, I feel as though the damage has been done by repeating this blanket statement. While readers have freely been engaging in this type of commentary for some time, it's been interesting to see authors chime in, where in some cases, there seems to be an emphasis on self-promotion over reflection. I'm not stereotyping and saying that all authors or even the authors I'm connected to respond with this tactic (because I really don't think they do!), but there are a few out there from my limited experience who seem to respond to this disc...

Review: Jerusalem Calls

I love books that bring further illumination to the culture and context of the Bible, purposefully seeking them out whenever I can. When I saw the subtitle of  Jerusalem Calls by Tammy Priest , I knew that I had to learn more about how the three Jewish feasts of Passover (Pesach), Pentecost (Shavuot), and The Feast of Booths (Sukkot) all point to our Lord Jesus. This book releases on August 4, 2026 and includes a beautiful testimony of God at work in His people's lives. Many thanks to Baker Books for providing a complimentary copy of this book for review consideration. All opinions are my own. Book Synopsis A Compelling Memoir About Judaism's Rich Traditions—and an Unexpected Encounter with Jesus Tammy Priest grew up in love with her Jewish heritage and identity. "I embraced it, dug into it, treasured it." Then one day, everything changed. At age 21, she heard God's audible voice speaking impossible yet unmistakable words: Jesus is the Messiah. It was both thril...